From Where the Orders Came

Army officers testify that two generals oversaw the torture and murder of civilians in Poonch

Illustration by Sukruti Anah Staneley
Illustration by Sukruti Anah Staneley
01 February, 2025

{ONE}

LATE INTO THE NIGHT between 21 and 22 December 2023, five officers rushed into a room at the Echo Company Base of the 48 Rashtriya Rifles, at the small ridge of Dera Ki Gali. The base overlooks the stretch of the Mughal Road between the towns of Thanamandi and Bafliaz, in Jammu and Kashmir’s border district of Poonch. The officers—in order of rank, Lieutenant General Sandeep Jain, Major General Maneesh Gupta, Brigadier Padmasambhava Acharya, Colonel Mithilesh Ojha and Major Rajkumar—were about to organise what they internally called Operation Pangai. While, officially, it was meant to be an intelligence-gathering operation to catch a group of militants, it would turn out to be one of the most well-documented incidents of mass torture in the dark history of army violence in Jammu and Kashmir.

The evening before, the army had suffered a major strategic failure. Militants had crossed the porous border and ambushed a military convoy about fifteen kilometres from the base. The losses were severe: three wounded, four dead, two of whom had been beheaded. To further sap morale, a video of the beheading had been shared online. The army also lost four rifles, along with several magazines. All of this took place in a region teeming with army posts—nearly one for every hamlet along the valley. “The army does not live with the people here, the people live with the army,” is a frequent saying among local residents.